THE TRAGIC STORY
OF ELSIE PAROUBEK
The story of the kidnapping and murder of a young
girl named Elsie Paroubek in the spring of 1911 is almost a forgotten tale in
the annals of Chicago crime. Few but the most dedicated historians remember
much about the case today, but at the time, her disappearance and the
subsequent search for her involved law enforcement officials from three states
and galvanized the people of Chicago. Nearly everyone was transfixed by the
newspaper articles dedicated to the story – a story that did not have a happy
ending.
To this day, the murder of Elsie Paroubek has never
been solved.
Eliška "Elsie" Paroubek’s mother was born
Karolína Vojáček in November 1869, in Míčov, East Bohemia, in what is now the
Czech Republic. Elsie's father, František (Frank) Paroubek, was born in Bohemia
in 1867. At the age of 15, he came to the United States, but later returned to
Bohemia for a ten-year span between 1882 and 1892. He and Karolina were married
in Bohemia in 1892 and returned to America. Frank worked as a painter while
Karolina took care of their home and raised a large brood of children. Eliška
(Elsie) was their seventh child. She was a happy child with light, golden hair,
blue eyes and a ready smile.
The only known photograph of Elsie Paroubek
On the morning of April 8, 1911, five-year-old
Elsie left her home at 2320 South Albany Avenue in Chicago, telling her mother
that she was going to visit “Auntie,” who was Mrs. Frank Trampota, who lived
around the corner at 2325 South Troy Street. Turning left on 22nd Street, then
left again on Troy, she met her nine-year-old cousin, Josie Trampota, and a
number of other children who were listening to an organ grinder on the street.
When the organ grinder moved on to the corner of 23rd Street, the children
followed him past Mrs. Trampota’s gate – except for Elsie, who stayed behind.
At that point, no one realized that she was missing.
Several
hours later, Elsie’s mother followed her daughter to the Trampota house. When
she arrived at her sister’s, Karolina learned that Elsie had never arrived.
Because the little girl had many friends in the neighborhood, the women assumed
that she must be visiting at another home, perhaps even spending the night and
returning in the morning. At 9:00 p.m. that evening, Frank Paroubek came home
from work and learned about Elsie’s absence. He was not as unconcerned as his
wife and sister-in-law and went immediately to the Hinman Street police station
to report her missing. Initially, the police agreed that it was likely she was
staying with friends, but when Elsie had not returned home the next morning,
Captain John Mahoney took personal charge of the search for the missing girl.
Detectives from several stations canvassed the
neighborhood and suspects soon emerged. A boy named John Jirowski told
detectives from the Maxwell Street station, led by Inspector Stephen K. Healey,
that he had seen a “gypsy” wagon (identified as Romani people in some accounts)
on Kedzie Avenue, a block west of Troy Street. There were two women on the
wagon and one of them was holding a little girl. The police knew of several
gypsy camps along the Des Plaines River, near Kedzie, and went down to speak
with the residents. They told investigators that one wagon had decamped and
left on the morning of April 9. While the idea of being “stolen by gypsies”
sounds far-fetched today, the theory was plausible at the time because Elsie’s
disappearance was almost identical to that of a girl named Lillian Wulff, who
had been found with gypsies four years earlier.
A gypsy family photographed in Chicago around 1911
Meanwhile,
Frank Paroubek had offered his life savings of $50 (about $1,165 today) as a
reward for the girl’s return. Detectives from Maxwell Street searched the
Italian neighborhoods around West 14th and South Halsted Streets, where it was
reported that a girl fitting Elsie’s description had been seen with an organ
grinder. Inspector Healey ordered that the drainage canals be dragged for the
child’s body on April 12, and again on April 15, and Illinois Governor Dan S.
Deneen asked the public to assist with the search. Soon, there were thousands
of people on the lookout for the little girl – but she was nowhere to be found.
Frank Paroubek, accompanied by Detectives Komorous
and Sheehan, went in search of the departed gypsy wagon, which was originally
believed to be headed for Round Lake, Illinois, a small town about 50 miles
northwest of Chicago. There were about seven wagons encamped there at the time
and local farmers were alerted to be on the watch for Elsie. Unfortunately,
many of them took it upon themselves to question the gypsies and attempt to
search their wagons. In the middle of the night, they broke camp, now headed
for Volo, Illinois. Volo residents reported a child matching Elsie’s
description with the gypsies, adding that she appeared to be “stupefied” or
“drugged” and partly covered with a blanket. They also attempted to search the
wagons, but the gypsies again escaped and departed for McHenry, Illinois, about
60 miles from Chicago. When the police finally caught up with them at McHenry,
they discovered the little girl was a gypsy and did not match Elsie at all,
other than they were about the same size and age.
According to the police, the gypsies often
kidnapped small children because of the “natural love of the wandering people
for blue-eyed, yellow-haired children.” The Chicago
Daily News consistently described Elsie as small, “having long curly golden
hair, blue eyes and pink chubby cheeks, with a prominent dimple in each. At the
time she disappeared she wore a red hat, a red dress, black stockings and high
top black boots.”
The entire city was on the lookout for the girl. On
April 17, Police Captain Mahoney received an anonymous telephone call saying
that a child of Elsie’s description had been seen with a man at a hotel in
Western Springs, Illinois. Again, detectives dispatched to the hotel found
nothing. In Sycamore, Illinois, the local police chief accompanied Frank
Paroubek when he investigated several gypsy wagons at Cherry Valley. But they
found no children resembling Elsie. Meanwhile, Hinman Street police officers
fielded reporters' questions about a $500 ransom note received by Karolina.
They "denied official knowledge of the communication, but admitted it
might be true.” Nothing ever came of the alleged ransom note.
Lillian Wulff, who advised police on how to proceed in case Elsie
Paroubek had been stolen by gypsies.
In the second week after Elsie’s disappearance,
Lillian Wulff, now age 11, came to the police to offer her assistance. She had
been the subject of an identical manhunt four years earlier when she had been
stolen by gypsies and forced to work for six days as a beggar. She was
recovered after being spotted by a farmer as she was walking behind a gypsy wagon
outside Momence, Illinois. Lillian provided what details she could about the
typical behavior of the gypsies and offered to lead a “rescue party” if Elsie
was found. One of the men who had kidnapped Lillian was tracked down in prison
and suggested that the police contact Elijah George – the “King of the Gypsies”
-- for help. George was found in Argyle, Wisconsin and brought to Joliet, but
“failed to give the desired information” and was released. At this point,
Inspector Healey again ordered the drainage canal dragged, along with a search
of wells, cisterns and other places into which Elsie might have fallen.
By April 30, Elsie had been missing for three weeks
and the city was in an uproar. The superintendent of schools, Mrs. Ella Flagg
Young, requested that all of the schoolchildren in the Chicago area organized
neighborhood searchers during their spring break. Around this same time, Frank
Paroubek, out of desperation, consulted a psychic medium, who said that Elson
was in Argo, Wisconsin. Chicago politician Charles J. Vopicka sent officers to
the area that she indicated, but there was no sign of the girl. The search went
from Illinois to Wisconsin, from Wisconsin to Minnesota and then back again to
Illinois – but with no luck.
In the midst of the investigation, something
sinister was going on. A few days after Elsie had vanished, Frank Paroubek
began receiving anonymous letters from an unknown source. The letters,
described as “insulting,” were all written in English, which he could not read.
He asked neighbors to translate. The letters claimed that Elsie had been taken
by someone who “hated” the Paroubeks and accused the family of mistreating her.
Frank was so angry about the accusations that he burned the letters.
Regardless, detectives attempted to follow up on the lead.
The Czech community in Chicago rallied to support
the family. All Czech-speaking policemen were put into plainclothes and
assigned to the investigation. The women’s auxiliary of the Club Bohemia also
helped with the search, creating what they called an “endless chain letter,”
which was mailed to every party of the city, asking that recipients mail copies
to everyone they knew. Various Czech-American politicians became involved and
the Bohemian Charitable Association offered a $500 reward. Other reward offers
poured in. Governor Deneen asked the legislature to revise the statutes so that
a reward could be offered by the state of Illinois. At that time, state laws
did not allow the offering of a reward for the apprehension of kidnappers, as
it did for murderers. Mayor Carter Harrison, Jr. contributed $25 ($600 in
today’s money) to a personal reward fund that was set up. Anton Cermak, then a
Chicago alderman, stated that if Elsie was not found by the next city council
meeting on May 1, he would call upon the city council to offer an even larger
reward.
The police were overwhelmed with calls. Every time
a girl in a red dress was sighted in a gypsy camp, the tip was called into the
police. By May 1, though, investigators had all but abandoned the idea that
Elsie had been stolen by gypsies and returned to their efforts of searching
wells and dragging rivers and canals. Judge Joseph Sabath objected to what he
said was a lackluster search. He claimed that the police hunt was becoming
"listless" because Elsie's parents were poor. He had been receiving
contributions to the reward fund from all over the country and increased his
own contribution to $100.
Meanwhile, Detectives Zahour and Zalasky were still
searching for the writer of the letters that had been sent to the Paroubeks.
They believed that the man lived near Madison and Robey Streets and that he
knew more about the disappearance than he was saying. Lieutenant Costello, supported
by Inspector Healey, flatly declared: "Elsie Paroubek fell into the
drainage canal from the Kedzie Avenue Bridge or near it. She was not
murdered." They believed the author of the letters witnessed her fall.
Their search turned up no trace of him, however.
The search of the gypsy camps continued. By May 7,
twenty-five camps had been searched and several false leads had turned up
nothing. Police Captain Mahoney sadly announced his belief that Elsie was dead,
but vowed that the police would continue to search for her body.
The drainage canal near Lockport in 1911
The search didn’t last much longer. Two days later,
an electrical engineer named George T. Scully, along with other employees of
the Lockport power plant near Joliet, discovered a body floating in the
drainage canal. At first they thought it was an animal from one of the nearby farms,
but three hours later, realizing that it looked like a child, they sent out a
boat to bring it to shore. Undertaker William Goodale, who was called to
examine the body, said that it appeared to fit the description of Elsie
Paroubek: "The description tallied to the shade of the hair, the texture
of the stockings, and the stuff and tint of the dress of little Elsie.” He
stated that he believed the body had been in the water for several weeks. It
was badly decomposed and original reports said there were “no marks of
violence” on the body.
Goodale notified Chicago authorities, who sent
Police Lieutenant Costello to the Paroubek home. When she saw the grim-faced
policeman on her doorstep, hat in hand, Karolina Paroubek cried out, “Mé drahé
dítě!” (My dear child!) and she begged to be told Elsie was alive. Frank was
taken to the Goodale funeral home at midnight. He said, "The clothes look
like Elsie's. But the face -- I can't recognize it. Her mother alone can tell.”
The next morning, Karolina was brought to the
Lockport undertaker’s parlor by trolley car and she positively identified the
dead girl as her daughter. She was quoted, “It's you, my darling. Thank God
we've found you and you're not in the hands of the gypsies.” For the next hour,
she paced back and forth or sat nervously with her husband in an adjoining
room. Frank held her hands and they wept and prayed together. Goodale, who had
followed the investigation into the girl’s disappearance in the newspapers,
made a statement to the police: “The body appears to have been in the water for
about a month, which would tally with the date of Elsie Paroubek's
disappearance. The child, when she left home, was without hat, and her clothing
tallies in every respect with that found on the dead body. There was no ring or
other ornament, and in that respect the descriptions correspond. Excepting only
as to the color of the eyes, which cannot be clearly observed as to color, the descriptions
are identical.”
Arrangements were made for an inquest, with Coroner
William Wunderlich of Will County presiding. Frank Paroubek was called as the
first witness. Disregarding questions asked of him by the coroner, Paroubek
insisted that his daughter had been murder. Through a translator, he told the
jury, “I am sure the gypsies stole my girl and then when they knew we were
after them they killed her and threw her body into the canal.”
At this assertion, chaos broke out in the jury
room. Karolina began screaming and ran from the funeral parlor where the
inquest was being held, shouting, “My Elsie is dead! She was murdered,
murdered!” Her husband and Detective Zelasky tried to calm her down but in her
extreme distress, she started running up and down the street, drawing a crowd
of curious onlookers. She insisted that she had known for three weeks that
“gypsies” had killed Elsie and that the police had done nothing about it. Frank
eventually was able to calm her down and assisted her in boarding a trolley car
for home.
The results of the inquest were inconclusive.
Coroner Wunderlich stated, “This case has attracted such attention that a
minute examination will be made. We will be content with no perfunctory inquest
such as this. The jury will refuse to state its convictions -- for it has none
-- until after the autopsy has been held. We want the stomach of the little
girl examined, and the lungs as well. The father charges murder. It is
certainly possible that he is right.”
During the autopsy, two physicians, E.A. Kingston
and W.R. Paddock, confirmed that Elsie had not drowned – there was no water in
her lungs. Kingston said that she had been “attacked” (a euphemism for rape)
and murdered before her body was placed in the water. Paddock said that there
was evidence that she had been “wounded” before she was killed. Lieutenant Costello
later told the press that she had been “mistreated,” which seemed to indicate
that her death had not been the work of gypsies. They also found “deep cuts” on
the left side of her face. Although these doctors reported “blue marks on the
throat as though the victim had been choked,” another examination by Dr. E.R.
LeCount and Dr. Warren H. Hunter of the Coroner’s Office revealed that Elsie
had been suffocated, not strangled. The official cause of death was listed as
“unknown.” Coroner Peter Hoffman agreed with Frank Paroubek as to the probably
circumstances of Elsie’s death – the little girl had been murdered, he
believed.
Coroner Hoffman announced, “It is our belief that
the abductor of the child suffocated her to death -- possibly by putting a hand
over her mouth." The coroner's report recommended that officials continue
to investigate. Inspector Healey immediately detailed detectives on a case that
had changed from a missing girl to a murdered one. He told reporters, “We have
one or two theories, but nothing specific enough to talk about. I intend to
place more men on the case tomorrow.” Meanwhile, Lieutenant Costello returned
to investigating the anonymous letters that were sent to the Paroubeks,
believing them to be the key to solving the case.
On the evening of May 9, Karolina was considerably
calmer and gave an interview to reporters at her home. Surrounded by friends
and neighbors, she told them, "Before the doctors found that Elsie's lungs
were free from water and discovered reasons for believing she had been
strangled, I knew she had been murdered. A picture of the crime has been in my
mind since the second week of her disappearance, and I am convinced that when
the truth is known, as it surely will be, it will be shown that she was choked
to death a week from April 8, when she was kidnapped on her way to visit her
'auntie.'" Karolina urged the police to find and punish the killers.
Judge Joseph Sabath
Unfortunately, the poor family had other matters to
deal with – Elsie’s funeral, which they could not afford. Karolina told Judge
Sabath that the search had exhausted all of the money the family had and there
was nothing left to bury her with. The judge gave her a check for $25 and
promised to raise more funds. Friends and family members pitched in and gave
money and also raised more money for the reward fund. Mrs. Sophie Johanes
raised over $50 by giving a benefit party and soliciting donations from Bohemians
on the West Coast.
Elsie’s funeral was held on May 12, on the front
lawn of the Paroubek home. Hours before it was scheduled to begin, mourners and
onlookers began to gather, numbering almost 3,000. They crowded into the yard,
around the house, along balconies and on porches of nearby homes. There was no
hall in the neighborhood large enough to hold them all. The Paroubeks had been
offered the use of a union hall, but Frank knew there were just too many people
and he didn’t want to turn anyone away. He said, “They have come to say goodbye
to my Elsie. Don't let them be disappointed.” Reserve police officers from the
Hinman Street station were tasked with keeping order and preventing the crowd
from breaking down the fence.
Elsie’s tiny white coffin was placed on two brass
stands, surrounded by lilies of the valley, roses and carnations sent by Mayor
Harrison, Judge Sabath and numerous city officials. Eight little girls dressed
all in white brought out huge sprays of lilies and roses and encircled the
stand. Someone brought out two chairs from the Paroubek home, set them near the
casket, placed a board across them and used it as a platform to hold the
hundreds of floral offerings. Karolina was seated at the head of the coffin,
while Frank and the other children stood nearby. The Paroubeks were not
religious, so a simple service was read by Rudolph Jaromir Psenka, editor of
the Bohemian Chicago Daily Svornost.
He spoke of the need to cooperate with the police to find Elsie’s killers. As
the undertaker went to lift the coffin into the hearse, Karolina begged him to
open it so she could see Elsie's face once more, but her relatives persuaded
her to let him go about his duties. Most of the attendees followed Elsie's
casket to Bohemian National Cemetery, where Psenka gave another address.
Police Chief John McWeeny
With the funeral over, the police investigation was
reinvigorated, despite the time that had passed. Police Chief John McWeeny
vowed to devote the entire Chicago police force to finding the killer. Alderman
Cermak asked Governor Deneen to increase the reward by another $200 and he
announced that he would, “Ask the governor to issue a proclamation calling upon
all the people of the state to interest themselves in this case, in order that
her murderer be apprehended." Coroner Peter Hoffman also started a public
reward fund, contributing $25 out of his own pocket.
Investigators soon had a suspect – a man named
Joseph Konesti. Described as a “bearded Bohemian” and a “hermit peddler,” he
was said to have “frequently enticed little girls to his hut by the drainage
canal” – the same canal where Elsie’s body was discovered. He lived in a shack
about a mile and a half from the Paroubek home and had been “frequently been
seen” nearby. The owner of the shack that he lived in, Mrs. David Shaughnessy,
told police that she had complained to Konesti about “bringing children around
the house,” and had evicted him on May 9. The following day, knowing he was
suspected by the police for the murder, he threw himself in front of a train
and was killed. Five days later, though, he was cleared of any wrongdoing.
On May 15, Frank Paroubek had information for the
investigators. He told detectives that he had spoken to a man he did not know,
who told him that he had seen Elsie later in the afternoon on April 8 on Kedzie
Avenue, south of 28th Street, long after she was supposed to have been taken by
gypsies. Lieutenant Costello tasked detectives with finding the man. A previous
sighting of Elsie had her walking toward the canal on South Troy Street, a half
block south of her aunt’s house. If the unknown man was telling the truth,
Elsie had been only three blocks away from the bridge. Costello had his own
thoughts about the case. He disagreed with the coroner’s report and had become
convinced that Elsie’s death was an accident. She had simply fallen into the
canal and died and if he could prove that she was closer to the canal than was
previously thought, it would give more weight to this theory. The problem was
that Inspector Healey had repeatedly dragged the ditches and canals during the
search and her body was not found. In addition, there had been no water in her lungs
and she had been molested. Costello was clinging to the initial examination by
Dr. Kingston, who told Costello that Elsie had drowned and there were no marks
of abuse on her body. He changed his report the following day, but Costello was
convinced the first report was accurate.
Costello followed his leads – which led nowhere –
while other detectives chased suspects of their own. At one point, they
surrounded a house near Madison and Robey Streets and then conducted a house to
house search on the southwest side for a former boarder in the Paroubek home.
They also looked for the unknown witness who passed on information to Frank and
the anonymous letter writer who seemed to know more than he should.
Unfortunately, none of these men – like Elsie’s killer himself – were ever
found. After more than a century, we still don’t know what really happened to
little Elsie Paroubek.
The same cannot be said for her parents, who were
destroyed by their daughter’s death. Two years later, on the anniversary of
Elsie’s funeral in 1913, Frank Paroubek died. He was only forty-five years old.
Karolina lived until December 9, 1927. In death, they have been reunited. All
three of them are buried together in Chicago’s Bohemian National Cemetery,
leaving a haunting mystery in their wake.
So very sad.
ReplyDelete